Quick answer
Atlanta’s pizza game is undeniably strong, rivaling established pizza cities with its own unique flavor and fiercely loyal fan base.
- Best overall
- Antico Pizza Napoletana
- Top pick
- Antico Pizza Napoletana
Top verdicts
- Antico Pizza Napoletana: Purists seeking true Neapolitan pizza in a lively, no-frills setting.
- Varuni Napoli: Those looking for a sophisticated Neapolitan dining experience with exceptional service and quality.
- O4W Pizza: Fans of thick, square Detroit-style pizza and unique, flavorful New York-style options.
From humble beginnings rooted in Italian immigrant communities to its current status as a diverse culinary hub, Atlanta's pizza journey reflects the city's growth. Early pizzerias served as community cornerstones, evolving alongside the city’s burgeoning food scene.
Today, you'll find an incredible array of styles: pristine Neapolitan pies blistered in wood-fired ovens, foldable New York-style slices perfect for on-the-go, thick and crispy Detroit-style squares, and creative American craft pizzas pushing flavor boundaries. There's a perfect pie for every preference and occasion.
Area map
All 10 spots at a glance
| # | Name | Style | Price | Area |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Antico Pizza Napoletana | Neapolitan | mid | West Midtown |
| 2 | Varuni Napoli | Neapolitan | mid | Midtown / Poncey-Highland |
| 3 | O4W Pizza | Detroit | mid | Old Fourth Ward |
| 4 | Nina & Rafi | Detroit | mid | Old Fourth Ward |
| 5 | Ammazza | Neapolitan | mid | Old Fourth Ward / Edgewood |
| 6 | Fellini's Pizza | New York | budget | Poncey-Highland |
| 7 | Slabtown Pizza | New York | mid | Grant Park |
| 8 | Glide Pizza | New York | budget | Old Fourth Ward / Inman Park |
| 9 | DaVinci's Pizzeria | New York | mid | Midtown |
| 10 | Mellow Mushroom | American Craft | mid | Midtown |
1Antico Pizza Napoletana
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Purists seeking true Neapolitan pizza in a lively, no-frills setting.
- Strengths
- West Midtown
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- Antico offers Atlanta's most authentic Neapolitan pizza experience, consistently recognized for its perfectly blistered crust and fresh, imported ingredients. Expect a bustling, communal atmosphere that feels straight out of Naples.
- What to order
- The Margherita D.O.P. is a must, showcasing the quality of their dough, sauce, and fresh mozzarella. Also try the Diavola if you like a spicy kick.
🕐 Opening hours
2Varuni Napoli
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those looking for a sophisticated Neapolitan dining experience with exceptional service and quality.
- Strengths
- Midtown / Poncey-Highland
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- Chef Luca Varuni brings generations of Neapolitan pizza-making tradition to Atlanta with his namesake restaurant. The pies are exquisite, complemented by a chic ambiance perfect for a more refined pizza outing.
- What to order
- The 'Spicy Hellboy' is a fan favorite, featuring spicy salami and Calabrian chiles. Their 'Oro Bianco' with white truffle oil is also a luxurious choice.
🕐 Opening hours
3O4W Pizza
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Fans of thick, square Detroit-style pizza and unique, flavorful New York-style options.
- Strengths
- Old Fourth Ward
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- O4W Pizza has carved out a unique niche with its celebrated Detroit-style and 'Grandma' pies. Their pizza is known for its distinct crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings, making it a local legend.
- What to order
- The Grandma Pie is absolutely essential – a thin, crispy square crust with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh garlic, mozzarella, and basil. For Detroit, try the 'Big Mack'.
🕐 Opening hours
4Nina & Rafi
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Enjoying delicious Detroit and NY-style pizza in a trendy, energetic setting with good drinks.
- Strengths
- Old Fourth Ward
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- Located in the historic Old Fourth Ward, Nina & Rafi offers a vibrant atmosphere alongside delicious New York and Detroit-style pizzas. It's a popular spot for both casual meals and lively gatherings.
- What to order
- Their Detroit-style pies are a highlight, especially the 'Big Poppa' with its crispy edges and rich flavors. Don't overlook their classic New York slices either.
🕐 Opening hours
5Ammazza
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Groups or couples seeking a well-rounded Neapolitan pizza experience with a great drink menu.
- Strengths
- Old Fourth Ward / Edgewood
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- Ammazza brings authentic Neapolitan pizza to the bustling Edgewood Avenue corridor. Their wood-fired pies are cooked to perfection, and the restaurant's spacious interior and outdoor seating make it a great option for groups.
- What to order
- The 'Vesuvio' with spicy soppressata and hot peppers provides a good kick. For a classic, their Margherita is consistently excellent.
🕐 Opening hours
6Fellini's Pizza
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Affordable, reliable New York-style pizza slices or whole pies, particularly after hours.
- Strengths
- Poncey-Highland
- Price / value
- $
- Why it made the list
- A true Atlanta institution, Fellini's has been serving up classic New York-style slices for decades. It's the go-to spot for a quick, satisfying bite, especially popular late into the night.
- What to order
- A classic Pepperoni slice is always a winner. Pair it with a side salad and their famous house dressing.
🕐 Opening hours
7Slabtown Pizza
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Authentic NY-style pizza lovers looking for quality ingredients and generous portions.
- Strengths
- Grant Park
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- Slabtown Pizza offers New York-style pies with a gourmet touch in the charming Grant Park neighborhood. Known for their high-quality ingredients and perfectly balanced crust, it's a neighborhood gem.
- What to order
- The 'Slabtown Supreme' is loaded with fresh toppings and a fantastic crust. Their garlic knots are also a must-try appetizer.
🕐 Opening hours
8Glide Pizza
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- A quick, authentic New York slice or a whole pie to go, especially convenient near the BeltLine.
- Strengths
- Old Fourth Ward / Inman Park
- Price / value
- $
- Why it made the list
- Glide Pizza delivers on the promise of a perfect New York slice, featuring thin, foldable crusts and classic toppings. It's a fantastic spot for a quick lunch or a casual meal while exploring the BeltLine.
- What to order
- Stick to the basics: a classic Cheese slice or a Pepperoni slice to fully appreciate their excellent dough and sauce.
🕐 Opening hours
9DaVinci's Pizzeria
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Families and Midtown residents looking for dependable, classic New York-style pizza and Italian American fare.
- Strengths
- Midtown
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- DaVinci's Pizzeria is a well-loved local spot offering traditional New York-style pizzas, calzones, and pastas. It's a reliable choice for consistent quality and friendly service in the heart of Midtown.
- What to order
- Their 'DaVinci's Original' pizza with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers is a hearty choice. Also try their garlic knots.
🕐 Opening hours
10Mellow Mushroom
restaurantQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those seeking creative, gourmet American-style pizzas with unique flavor combinations and a fun atmosphere.
- Strengths
- Midtown
- Price / value
- $$
- Why it made the list
- While a larger chain, Mellow Mushroom started in Atlanta and remains a beloved local favorite for its unique stone-baked pizzas, creative toppings, and vibrant, artistic decor. It offers a distinct American craft pizza experience.
- What to order
- The 'Holy Shiitake Pie' with three types of mushrooms, caramelized onions, and truffle aioli is a standout. Their 'Mega-Veggie' is also popular.
🕐 Opening hours
Frequently asked questions
What's the best Neapolitan pizza in Atlanta?
For truly authentic Neapolitan pizza, Antico Pizza Napoletana is often cited as the top choice, known for its traditional ingredients and wood-fired crust. Varuni Napoli and Ammazza also offer exceptional Neapolitan pies with unique ambiance and menu variations.
Where can I find authentic New York-style pizza by the slice?
Fellini's Pizza is an Atlanta institution for classic New York-style slices, perfect for a quick bite or late-night craving. Glide Pizza in the Old Fourth Ward and DaVinci's Pizzeria in Midtown also serve excellent, foldable NY-style slices that hit the spot.
Is Detroit-style pizza popular in Atlanta?
Yes, Detroit-style pizza has gained significant popularity in Atlanta. O4W Pizza is renowned for its crispy-edged square pies, especially their famous Grandma Pie. Nina & Rafi also offers fantastic Detroit-style options alongside their New York varieties.
Are there any gluten-free or vegan pizza options available?
Many pizzerias in Atlanta are accommodating. Mellow Mushroom, for example, is well-known for its gluten-free crust options and extensive vegetarian and vegan-friendly toppings. Other spots often offer gluten-free crusts upon request, but it's always best to call ahead and confirm their specific offerings and cross-contamination policies.
What's the price range for a good pizza in Atlanta?
The price for a pizza in Atlanta typically ranges from $10-$30 per person. Casual slice shops like Fellini's or Glide Pizza offer slices for $4-$7, while a full, gourmet Neapolitan pie at places like Antico or Varuni Napoli can range from $18-$30 for a personal or sharing size.
Do Atlanta pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Most of Atlanta's popular pizzerias offer takeout, with many also partnering with third-party delivery services like Uber Eats, DoorDash, and Grubhub. It's always best to check the individual restaurant's website or preferred delivery platform for current options and availability.
Is it customary to tip at pizza places in Atlanta?
Yes, it is customary to tip for table service at sit-down pizza restaurants in Atlanta, typically 15-20% of the bill. For takeout orders, leaving a smaller tip (10% or a few dollars) is appreciated for the staff preparing your order, though not strictly required. For delivery, a tip of 15-20% is expected for the driver.
What neighborhoods are best for a pizza crawl?
The Old Fourth Ward is an excellent neighborhood for a pizza crawl, boasting several top-tier spots within walking or short driving distance, including O4W Pizza, Nina & Rafi, Ammazza, and Glide Pizza. West Midtown and parts of Midtown also offer a high concentration of quality pizzerias.