Quick answer
Chicago's deep-dish pizza scene spans three distinct styles: classic deep-dish (Lou Malnati's), stuffed (Giordano's), and caramelized crust pan pizza (Pequod's). Lou Malnati's is the most recommended overall, but each style has its loyalists. This list, curated from hundreds of Reddit posts across r/chicago, r/AskChicago, and r/chicagofood, covers the 12 pizzerias that real Chicagoans recommend.
- Best overall
- Lou Malnati's Pizzeria — 4.4★ (12,550 reviews)
- Best cult favorite
- Pequod's Pizza — caramelized crust
- Best newcomer
- Milly's Pizza In The Pan — 4.8★
- Last verified
- 2026-03
Top verdicts
- Lou Malnati's: The single most recommended deep-dish in Chicago across Reddit.
- Pequod's: The cult favorite with caramelized cheese crust.
- Milly's: The highest-rated at 4.8★ — order ahead, they sell out daily.
Chicago's deep-dish pizza, with medium pies (serving 2-3) costing $18-$28, offers a range of experiences, and Lou Malnati's is the most consistently recommended spot by Chicagoans on Reddit. This guide, backed by Reddit users, explores the city's most iconic dish, from butter-crust classics to caramelized-crust cult favorites.
Chicago's deep-dish pizza scene offers a range of experiences, with a medium pie (serving 2-3) costing between $18-$28. Lou Malnati's is the most consistently recommended spot, known for its classic butter-crust style that locals and Reddit users rave about.
Chicago invented deep-dish pizza, and the debate over who does it best has raged since 1943. We analyzed hundreds of Reddit posts across r/chicago, r/AskChicago, and r/chicagofood to find the 12 pizzerias that actual Chicagoans recommend — not just the tourist-trap chains that show up on every generic list.
Three distinct styles compete for the crown: classic deep-dish (butter crust, sauce on top), stuffed pizza (extra dough layer, even more cheese), and caramelized crust pan pizza (cheese baked into the edges). Each has its partisans, and you should try at least two styles while you're here.
Pizzeria Map
How we built this list
We analyzed 500+ Reddit posts and 3,000+ comments across r/chicago, r/AskChicago, r/chicagofood, and r/pizza spanning 2019 to 2025. Restaurants were ranked by frequency of independent recommendations. Every spot was mentioned in at least 3 separate threads by different users. Upvote counts, commenter credibility, and recency were all weighted. Google Places API data verified ratings and current operating status.
1Lou Malnati's Pizzeria
Deep-Dish PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- The definitive Chicago deep-dish with butter crust and chunky tomato sauce
- Strengths
- 4.4 from 12,550 reviews. Multiple locations. Ship nationwide
- Limitations
- Long waits on weekends at popular locations
- Price / value
- $18-$30 · 4.4★
- What to order
- The Malnati Classic: butter crust, sausage, extra cheese, vine-ripened tomato sauce.
🕐 Hours
2Pequod's Pizza
Caramelized Crust Pan PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- The caramelized cheese crust that converts deep-dish skeptics
- Strengths
- 4.4 from 16,058 reviews. Open until 2 AM
- Limitations
- Very long waits on weekends (1-2 hours)
- Price / value
- $16-$28 · 4.4★
- What to order
- Sausage and pepperoni pan pizza. The caramelized cheese crust IS the star.
🕐 Hours
3Giordano's
Stuffed Deep-Dish PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- Stuffed pizza with dramatic cheese pulls and maximum cheesiness
- Strengths
- 4.5 from 24,809 reviews. Many locations
- Limitations
- Some locals call it the McDonalds of deep dish
- Price / value
- $18-$32 · 4.5★
- What to order
- Classic stuffed cheese pizza. Add sausage for protein.
🕐 Hours
4Gino's East
Deep-Dish PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- Cornmeal crust deep-dish in a legendary graffiti-covered restaurant
- Strengths
- 4.7 from 18,766 reviews. Iconic atmosphere. Since 1966
- Limitations
- Tourist-heavy. Cornmeal crust is polarizing
- Price / value
- $18-$30 · 4.7★
- What to order
- The Meaty Legend or classic cheese.
🕐 Hours
5Milly's Pizza In The Pan
Caramelized Pan PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- Highest-rated deep-dish in Chicago if you get there before sellout
- Strengths
- 4.8 highest on list. Second location in Berwyn
- Limitations
- Very limited hours (Wed-Sun 4-8 PM). Sells out
- Price / value
- $16-$26 · 4.8★
- What to order
- Order ahead at millyspizzachi.com. Sausage pie.
🕐 Hours
6George's Deep Dish
New-Wave Deep-DishQuick comparison
- Best for
- Adventurous eaters wanting new-wave deep-dish
- Strengths
- 4.7. Greek pastry crust. Eater-approved
- Limitations
- Far north in Edgewater. Limited hours
- Price / value
- $18-$28 · 4.7★
- What to order
- The Halas' Classic.
🕐 Hours
7Pizzeria Uno
Original Deep-DishQuick comparison
- Best for
- Pizza history at the literal birthplace of deep-dish
- Strengths
- Since 1943. Historic River North location
- Limitations
- Touristy. NOT the Uno chain
- Price / value
- $16-$28 · 4.3★
- What to order
- The Numero Uno: sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers, mushrooms.
🕐 Hours
8Pizzeria Due
Classic Deep-DishQuick comparison
- Best for
- The Uno experience without the wait
- Strengths
- Same recipes as Uno. Shorter waits. Cozier
- Limitations
- Often overlooked
- Price / value
- $16-$28 · 4.3★
- What to order
- Deep-dish with sausage. Less crowded, more consistent.
🕐 Hours
9Bartoli's Pizzeria
Deep-Dish / StuffedQuick comparison
- Best for
- Lighter deep-dish near Wrigleyville with Gino's East roots
- Strengths
- 4.5. Gino's founder's grandson. Pizza by the slice
- Limitations
- Not downtown. Dinner hours only
- Price / value
- $14-$26 · 4.5★
- What to order
- Nonna Bartoli's Special: spinach and cheese stuffed.
🕐 Hours
10Labriola Ristorante
Deep-Dish / ItalianQuick comparison
- Best for
- Great deep-dish on the Magnificent Mile without tourist-trap vibe
- Strengths
- 4.4 from 4,453 reviews. Full Italian menu. Bakery
- Limitations
- Higher price point
- Price / value
- $18-$32 · 4.4★
- What to order
- Sausage deep-dish. Also has an excellent bakery counter.
🕐 Hours
11Burt's Place
Caramelized Pan PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- The original caramelized crust by Burt Katz
- Strengths
- 4.6. Birthplace of caramelized crust. Bourdain-approved
- Limitations
- Suburban (~30 min). Must order ahead
- Price / value
- $18-$30 · 4.6★
- What to order
- Pan pizza with sausage. Order ahead.
🕐 Hours
12Pizano's Pizza & Pasta
Deep-Dish PizzaQuick comparison
- Best for
- Quieter Malnati-family alternative in the Loop
- Strengths
- Malnati family lineage. Loop location
- Limitations
- Lower rating than Lou's
- Price / value
- $16-$28 · 4.1★
- What to order
- Rudy's Special: sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers.
🕐 Hours
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best deep-dish pizza in Chicago?
Lou Malnati's is the most consistently recommended deep-dish pizza in Chicago across Reddit. Their Malnati Classic with butter crust, sausage, and chunky tomato sauce is the gold standard. Pequod's is a close second, famous for its caramelized cheese crust.
What's the difference between deep-dish and stuffed pizza?
Deep-dish has a thick, buttery crust pressed into a deep pan with cheese on the bottom and chunky tomato sauce on top. Stuffed pizza (like Giordano's) has an extra thin layer of dough on top, sealed like a pie. Stuffed is thicker and has more cheese.
Where do Chicago locals actually eat deep-dish?
Most locals name Lou Malnati's as their go-to. Pequod's is the cult favorite for its caramelized crust. Newer spots like Milly's and George's Deep Dish are gaining serious followings.
How long does it take to get a deep-dish pizza?
Plan for 30-45 minutes from ordering. Deep-dish is baked fresh. Pro tip: call ahead or order online.
Is Giordano's or Lou Malnati's better?
Different styles. Lou's is classic deep-dish with butter crust, lighter. Giordano's is stuffed pizza, thicker and cheesier. Reddit favors Lou's for quality.
How much does a deep-dish pizza cost?
A medium (serves 2-3) costs $18-$28. A large (3-4 people) runs $24-$35. Budget about $15-20 per person including a drink.
What is caramelized crust deep-dish?
A style where cheese is baked along the pan edge, creating a crispy golden ring. Pequod's, Milly's, and Burt's Place specialize in this style, invented by Burt Katz.
🎟️ Book Chicago Experiences
Tours and activities hand-picked for this guide
Experiences via Viator — free cancellation on most tours
