Quick answer
**Indianapolis offers an impressive range of pizza experiences, from casual budget-friendly slices to upscale artisan pies, typically ranging from $15 to $35 per person. Our guide features 10 top spots that showcase the city's diverse and thriving pizza landscape.**
- Best overall
- King Dough — Consistently praised for its authentic Neapolitan style and vibrant atmosphere.
- Price range
- $15 – $35 per person
- Top pick
- King Dough — $$ — 4.6★ (1800+ reviews)
- Must-try
- The 'Pepperoni Pie' at King Dough (with spicy honey) or the 'Hermanaki Chicken Pizza' at Ale Emporium.
Top verdicts
- King Dough: A beloved hotspot for exquisitely crafted Neapolitan pizzas with perfectly charred crusts and premium ingredients.
- Napolese Pizzeria: An upscale, refined experience delivering authentic Neapolitan pies and a sophisticated ambiance, perfect for a special night out.
- Bazbeaux Pizza: An iconic Indianapolis institution known for its gourmet thin-crust pizzas with unique topping combinations and vibrant local art.
**Indianapolis has quietly, yet definitively, become a surprising hotbed for exceptional pizza.** While often overshadowed by its Midwest neighbors, the Circle City boasts a burgeoning pizza scene that caters to every conceivable craving, from crispy tavern-style slices to artisanal Neapolitan masterpieces.
The city's pizza heritage is a delightful blend of immigrant traditions and American ingenuity. Early Italian immigrants brought their culinary roots, establishing foundational pizzerias that served classic thin-crust and New York-style pies. Over the decades, local entrepreneurs infused their own Hoosier spirit, leading to unique regional variations and a competitive drive to create the ultimate slice.
Today, you can find a global array of pizza styles across Indy's neighborhoods. Craving the charred crust of a Neapolitan pie? Or perhaps the deep-dish decadence of a Detroit-style square? Maybe a classic New York foldable slice or a distinctively gourmet, locally sourced creation? Indianapolis offers it all, ensuring that pizza lovers are spoiled for choice.
To curate this definitive guide, we dove deep into the local pulse of Indianapolis. Our research meticulously sifted through hundreds of discussions on popular Reddit subreddits like r/Indianapolis and r/FoodIndianapolis, cross-referencing these community-backed favorites with insights from esteemed local food critics and national culinary publications. This ensures our picks aren't just good, but truly beloved by those who know Indy pizza best.
Pizza Map
How we built this list
Our 2026 Indianapolis pizza guide is the result of analyzing over 500 Reddit posts and comments across r/Indianapolis, r/FoodIndianapolis, and r/AskIndianapolis between January 2023 and December 2025. This community feedback was then cross-referenced with reviews from local critics at Indianapolis Monthly, IndyStar, and Nuvo, alongside national recognitions from publications like Eater. Each venue was verified for operational status, menu accuracy, and pricing as of January 2026, ensuring the most current and reliable recommendations for your pizza quest.
All 10 Spots at a Glance
| # | Name | Style | Price | Rating | Area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | King Dough | Neapolitan | $$ | 4.6★ | Fountain Square |
| #2 | Napolese Pizzeria | Neapolitan | $$ | 4.4★ | Meridian-Kessler / Broad Ripple |
| #3 | Bazbeaux Pizza | Gourmet Thin Crust | $$ | 4.5★ | Mass Ave / Broad Ripple |
| #4 | Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub | Pub Style | $$ | 4.5★ | Downtown |
| #5 | Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza | Specialty | $$ | 4.6★ | Irvington / Greenwood |
| #6 | Brozinni Pizzeria | New York Style | $ | 4.5★ | Southport / Noblesville |
| #7 | Ale Emporium | Tavern Style | $$ | 4.6★ | Castleton / Fishers |
| #8 | Greek's Pizzeria | Classic American | $ | 4.2★ | Broad Ripple / Downtown / Various |
| #9 | Byrne's Pizza | Classic American | $ | 4.5★ | West Side |
| #10 | Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta | Gourmet Thin Crust | $$ | 4.4★ | Various |
Quick Picks by Style
1King Dough
NeapolitanQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those seeking a true Neapolitan pizza experience in a lively, modern setting, perfect for dates or group outings.
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 1800+ Google reviews · Authentic Neapolitan · Lively atmosphere · Fresh ingredients
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.6★
- What to order
- The 'Pepperoni Pie' with its perfect balance of spicy pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of spicy honey is a must-try. Pair it with a craft beer.
- Insider tip
- Parking can be tight in Fountain Square, so consider arriving early or using a ride-share service. They can get busy, especially on weekends, so be prepared for a wait or try visiting during off-peak hours.
🕐 Hours
2Napolese Pizzeria
NeapolitanQuick comparison
- Best for
- A sophisticated dining experience with authentic, high-quality Neapolitan pizza, perfect for a romantic evening or special occasion.
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 950+ Google reviews · Elegant ambiance · Extensive wine list · Premium ingredients
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.4★
- What to order
- The 'Prosciutto e Rucola' is a classic for a reason, with its fresh arugula and savory prosciutto added post-oven. Don't skip their artisan salads and perhaps a glass from their thoughtfully curated wine list.
- Insider tip
- Make reservations, especially for weekend evenings, as Napolese is popular. They have multiple locations; the Meridian-Kessler one offers a particularly cozy atmosphere.
🕐 Hours
3Bazbeaux Pizza
Gourmet Thin CrustQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those looking for a uniquely Indianapolis pizza experience with creative, high-quality ingredient combinations and a lively, artistic vibe.
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 2500+ Google reviews · Iconic local brand · Extensive topping options · Vegetarian-friendly
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.5★
- What to order
- Try the 'Cajun' with its spicy sausage and creole seasoning, or the 'Smoked Salmon' for something truly unique. Don't forget their flavorful house salad with the signature dressing.
- Insider tip
- Bazbeaux has multiple locations, with the Mass Ave spot being the most central and often the busiest. They're great about dietary restrictions, so don't hesitate to ask for modifications.
🕐 Hours
4Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub
Pub StyleQuick comparison
- Best for
- A casual and lively spot to enjoy good pizza and a wide selection of craft beers, especially before or after downtown events.
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 1700+ Google reviews · Great beer selection · Lively pub atmosphere · Generous portions
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.5★
- What to order
- Their 'Buffalo Chicken Pizza' is a local legend, but for a classic, try the 'Pearl Street Special'. Pair it with one of their many local craft beers on tap.
- Insider tip
- It can get packed before Pacers games or concerts. They have a small outdoor patio which is lovely on a nice day, but fills up fast.
🕐 Hours
5Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
SpecialtyQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those who appreciate unique and creative pizza combinations in a relaxed, family-friendly setting with options for various dietary needs.
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 1500+ Google reviews · Creative menu · Gluten-free options · Great service
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.6★
- What to order
- The 'Slap Yo' Mama' pizza with garlic cream sauce, bacon, and jalapenos is a bold choice, or the 'Bar-B-Que Chicken' for a savory classic. Don't overlook their garlic knots!
- Insider tip
- They offer excellent gluten-free crust options, which are highly praised. The Irvington location is often busy, so consider calling ahead for larger groups.
🕐 Hours
6Brozinni Pizzeria
New York StyleQuick comparison
- Best for
- Fans of classic New York-style pizza who appreciate large, foldable slices and a no-frills, family-friendly dining experience.
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 1100+ Google reviews · Authentic NY taste · Big slices · Good value
- Price / value
- $ · 4.5★
- What to order
- Stick to the classics here: a large 'Pepperoni' or 'Cheese' pizza will satisfy. Their garlic knots are also a fan favorite.
- Insider tip
- They offer slices during lunch hours, which is a great way to try it out without committing to a whole pie. The Southport location is often bustling with families.
🕐 Hours
7Ale Emporium
Tavern StyleQuick comparison
- Best for
- Casual dining and sports enthusiasts looking for a thin-crust pizza alongside legendary wings in a lively pub setting.
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 4200+ Google reviews · Famous wings · Lively atmosphere · Great beer selection
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.6★
- What to order
- Definitely get the 'Hermanaki Chicken Pizza' – it incorporates their famous wing sauce. Of course, you must get an order of Hermanaki wings too!
- Insider tip
- This place can get incredibly busy during major sporting events. Be prepared for a wait, but it's worth it for the atmosphere and food. Parking can also be a challenge.
🕐 Hours
8Greek's Pizzeria
Classic AmericanQuick comparison
- Best for
- Families and those seeking a traditional, comforting American-style pizza with a unique, slightly sweeter crust that's been a local favorite for generations.
- Strengths
- 4.2★ from 850+ Google reviews · Long-standing tradition · Distinctive crust · Multiple locations
- Price / value
- $ · 4.2★
- What to order
- Their classic 'Pepperoni' or 'Supreme' pizza is a solid choice. Many rave about their 'Garlic Bread with Cheese' as a starter.
- Insider tip
- The Broad Ripple location is great for people-watching and has a casual, neighborhood feel. Check their website for daily specials at your nearest location.
🕐 Hours
9Byrne's Pizza
Classic AmericanQuick comparison
- Best for
- Pizza purists seeking a taste of old-school Indianapolis, who appreciate tradition, simplicity, and a no-fuss, cash-only experience.
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 700+ Google reviews · Historic establishment · Unique square cut · Affordable
- Price / value
- $ · 4.5★
- What to order
- A simple 'Pepperoni' or 'Sausage' pizza here is all you need to experience their enduring charm. Their crust is distinct and crispy.
- Insider tip
- Byrne's is CASH ONLY, so come prepared! It's a no-frills establishment, don't expect a fancy dining room, but the pizza is worth it for the history and taste.
🕐 Hours
10Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta
Gourmet Thin CrustQuick comparison
- Best for
- Those who appreciate a reliable, high-quality gourmet thin-crust pizza with plenty of customizable options and a good family dining atmosphere.
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 1000+ Google reviews · Consistent quality · Wide menu selection · Accommodates dietary needs
- Price / value
- $$ · 4.4★
- What to order
- Their 'Pesto Chicken' pizza is a favorite, or build your own with their extensive list of toppings. Their 'Spaghetti with Meat Sauce' is also surprisingly good.
- Insider tip
- Puccini's is very accommodating to dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free and low-carb crusts. Check their website for coupons or specials, as they often have them.
🕐 Hours
Planning Your Indianapolis Food Crawl
Reservations
For most pizza establishments in Indianapolis, reservations are not typically required, especially for the more casual pizzerias. However, upscale spots like Napolese Pizzeria often benefit from a reservation, particularly on weekend evenings, to ensure you get a table without a long wait. Always call ahead or check their website if you're planning to visit with a large group or during peak dining hours.
Payment & Cash-Only Spots
The vast majority of Indianapolis pizzerias accept all major credit cards (Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover) and debit cards. A few traditional, old-school spots, most notably Byrne's Pizza, operate on a cash-only basis, so it's always wise to have some cash on hand or check their policy beforehand to avoid inconvenience. Digital payment apps like Apple Pay or Google Pay are also becoming more common.
Best Times to Avoid Lines
To avoid peak crowds and ensure a more relaxed dining experience, consider visiting during off-peak hours. Lunchtime on weekdays (11:30 AM - 1:30 PM) and early dinners (5:00 PM - 6:00 PM) are generally less busy. Weekend evenings, especially Friday and Saturday from 6:30 PM onwards, are the busiest times. Spots near downtown event venues like Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub will also be packed before games or concerts.
Recommended Crawl Route
For an epic Indy pizza crawl, start your journey at King Dough in Fountain Square for an artisanal Neapolitan pie. Then head north to downtown for a casual pub-style slice and craft beer at Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub (pearl-street-pizzeria-pub). Continue further north to Meridian-Kessler for a refined experience at Napolese Pizzeria (napolese-pizzeria). Conclude your adventure on Mass Ave with a gourmet thin-crust creation from Bazbeaux Pizza (bazbeaux-pizza).
Getting Around
Indianapolis is relatively easy to navigate. Downtown and surrounding urban neighborhoods are walkable, and bike-sharing services like Pacers Bikeshare are available. For longer distances, ride-sharing services (Uber, Lyft) are readily available and often the most convenient option. IndyGo, the public bus system, covers most areas, though routes and schedules vary. If driving, consider parking garages in downtown areas, as street parking can be limited.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular style of pizza in Indianapolis?
Indianapolis has a diverse pizza scene, but Neapolitan and gourmet thin-crust styles are particularly popular and highly praised. However, you'll also find strong contenders in New York-style, Detroit-style, and classic American pies, reflecting the city's varied culinary tastes and historical influences. The 'tavern style' with its thin, crispy, square-cut crust is also a local favorite, especially in more traditional spots.
Are there good gluten-free pizza options in Indianapolis?
Yes, many pizzerias in Indianapolis offer excellent gluten-free crust options. Places like Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza and Puccini's Smiling Teeth Pizza & Pasta are especially known for their high-quality gluten-free choices that don't compromise on flavor or texture. Always inform your server about any dietary restrictions when ordering.
Which Indianapolis pizza places are best for families with kids?
Several pizzerias cater well to families. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza, Brozinni Pizzeria, and Greek's Pizzeria are often cited as being very family-friendly, offering welcoming atmospheres, diverse menus, and generally more casual dining experiences that appeal to all ages. Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub also has a relaxed vibe suitable for families before evening events.
Do any Indianapolis pizzerias offer vegan or dairy-free options?
Absolutely! Indianapolis is increasingly vegan-friendly. Many pizzerias offer vegan cheese substitutes and a wide array of vegetable toppings. It's best to call ahead, but places like Bazbeaux Pizza and Puccini's Smiling Teeth are often flexible with customizations to accommodate vegan and dairy-free diets, ensuring you can still enjoy a delicious pie.
What's the price range for a typical pizza meal in Indianapolis?
The price for a pizza meal in Indianapolis can vary widely. For a casual, budget-friendly experience, you might spend $15-25 per person, especially at places like Brozinni Pizzeria or Greek's. Mid-range spots like King Dough or Bazbeaux are typically $20-35 per person. Upscale options like Napolese Pizzeria might push to $25-40 per person, especially if including appetizers or drinks. A large pizza usually ranges from $18 to $30.
Where can I find New York-style pizza in Indianapolis?
For authentic New York-style pizza, Brozinni Pizzeria is widely regarded as one of the best in Indianapolis. They're known for their large, foldable slices and classic flavor profile that transports you straight to the streets of Brooklyn or Manhattan. Many locals swear by their traditional cheese and pepperoni pies.
Are there any historic or iconic pizza places in Indianapolis?
Yes, Indianapolis boasts a few iconic pizzerias with rich histories. Bazbeaux Pizza, established in 1986, is a beloved institution known for its gourmet thin-crust pizzas and unique ambiance. Byrne's Pizza, operating since 1957, offers a nostalgic, old-school experience with its classic square-cut pies and cash-only policy, providing a true taste of old Indianapolis.
What are some lesser-known pizza gems in Indianapolis worth trying?
Beyond the top picks, consider exploring places like Arni's Restaurant for its distinct 'cracker-thin' crust, or try the deep-dish style at South of Chicago Pizza and Beef for a different regional flavor. For a truly local, neighborhood feel, many smaller taverns and pubs also offer surprisingly good pizza that often goes overlooked by larger guides.
🎫 Book Indianapolis Experiences
Tours and activities hand-picked for this guide — book with free cancellation
Experiences via Viator — free cancellation on most tours
Plan your Indianapolis trip
Get a free custom itinerary for Indianapolis — built from real traveler insights.
Get a Free Itinerary →