Quick answer
New York City's pizza scene offers options ranging from $3 to $35, with Joe's Pizza being a top recommendation for its classic NY slice. This guide focuses on spots favored by New Yorkers and pizza enthusiasts, avoiding tourist traps to highlight truly exceptional slices and pies.
- Best overall
- Ops
- Price/value range
- $3 – $7
- Top-ranked pick
- Joe's Pizza — $3–$6
- Last verified
- 2026-03
Top verdicts
- Joe's Pizza: The quintessential NYC slice.
- L'Industrie Pizzeria: The current reigning champion of NYC slices on Reddit.
- Lucali: The most romantic pizza experience in NYC.
New York City's pizza scene offers options ranging from $3 to $35, with Joe's Pizza being a top recommendation for its classic NY slice. This guide focuses on spots favored by New Yorkers and pizza enthusiasts, avoiding tourist traps to highlight truly exceptional slices and pies.
New York City invented the American pizza slice. From coal-oven originals dating back to 1905 to today's Instagram-famous Sicilian squares, the city's pizza scene is the deepest and most competitive in the world. But with thousands of pizzerias across five boroughs, finding the genuinely great ones means wading through a lot of mediocre cheese.
We analyzed hundreds of Reddit posts from r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/pizza, and r/nyc to find the spots that actual New Yorkers and serious pizza enthusiasts recommend over and over. Skip the tourist traps — these are the slices and pies worth your time.
Pizza Map
1. Joe's Pizza
How we built this list
We analyzed 200+ Reddit posts and 2,000+ comments across r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/pizza, and r/nyc — spanning 2020 to 2025. Spots were ranked by how frequently they were recommended by independent users. Every pizzeria on this list was mentioned in at least 5 separate threads by different people. We weighted long-term New Yorker picks more heavily than tourist posts.
All 19 Spots at a Glance
| # | Name | Style | Price | Rating | Area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Joe's Pizza | NY Slice | $3–$6 | 4.5★ | Greenwich Village |
| #2 | L'Industrie Pizzeria | NY Slice | $4–$7 | 4.7★ | Williamsburg |
| #3 | Lucali | Whole Pie | $28–$35 (whole pie, cash only) | 4.2★ | Carroll Gardens |
| #4 | Di Fara Pizza | Classic NY | $5–$35 | 4.2★ | Midwood |
| #5 | Prince Street Pizza | Sicilian | $4–$7 | 4.4★ | Nolita |
| #6 | Scarr's Pizza | NY Slice | $4–$7 | 4.4★ | Lower East Side |
| #7 | John's of Bleecker Street | Coal-Oven | $18–$28 (whole pies only) | 4.6★ | Greenwich Village |
| #8 | Paulie Gee's | Wood-Fired | $18–$26 | 4.5★ | Greenpoint |
| #9 | Roberta's | Wood-Fired | $16–$24 | 4.4★ | Bushwick |
| #10 | Mama's Too | NY Slice | $4–$7 | 4.2★ | Upper West Side |
| #11 | NY Pizza Suprema | NY Slice | $3–$6 | 4.6★ | Midtown |
| #12 | Totonno's | Coal-Oven | $18–$28 | 4.1★ | Coney Island |
| #13 | Patsy's Pizzeria (East Harlem Original) | Coal-Oven | $16–$25 | 4.5★ | East Harlem |
| #14 | Una Pizza Napoletana | Neapolitan | $22–$30 | 4.3★ | Lower East Side |
| #15 | Ops | Neapolitan | $16–$24 | 4.6★ | Bushwick |
| #16 | Paulie Gee's Slice Shop | NY Slice | $4–$7 | 4.5★ | Greenpoint |
| #17 | Luigi's Pizza | NY Slice | $3–$5 | 4.6★ | Park Slope / South Brooklyn |
| #18 | Williamsburg Pizza | NY Slice | $3–$6 | 4.3★ | Williamsburg |
| #19 | F&F Pizzeria | Grandma | $4–$7 | 4.5★ | Carroll Gardens |
Quick Picks by Budget
💰 Budget ($3–$7/slice)
Joe's Pizza — Classic $3 slice
L'Industrie — Best burrata slice
NY Pizza Suprema — Near Penn Station
🍕 Whole Pies ($16–$28)
John's of Bleecker — Best coal-oven
Paulie Gee's — Best wood-fired
Ops — Best Neapolitan
✨ Splurge ($28–$35)
Lucali — Candlelit romance, BYOB
Una Pizza Napoletana — Purist Neapolitan
Di Fara — NYC pizza legend
Best New York Pizza by Occasion
🎉 Date Night
Lucali — Candlelit, BYOB
🏃 Quick Bite
Joe's Pizza — Classic slice
👨👩👧 Family
John's of Bleecker — Whole pies
1Joe's Pizza
NY Slice
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for ny slice in Greenwich Village. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Greenwich Village
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 10,151 Google reviews · NY Slice · Greenwich Village
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $3–$6 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu10:00 – 03:00Fri–Sat10:00 – 04:00Sun10:00 – 03:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Greenwich Village. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
2L'Industrie Pizzeria
NY Slice
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for ny slice in Williamsburg. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Williamsburg
- Strengths
- 4.7★ from 5,461 Google reviews · NY Slice · Williamsburg
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $4–$7 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Sun12:00 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Williamsburg. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
3Lucali
Whole Pie
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for whole pie in Carroll Gardens. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Whole Pie lovers looking for an authentic experience in Carroll Gardens
- Strengths
- 4.2★ from 3,005 Google reviews · Whole Pie · Carroll Gardens
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $28–$35 (whole pie, cash only) · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for whole pie.
- What to order
- Their signature whole pie preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon17:00 – 22:00Wed–Thu17:00 – 22:00Fri–Sat17:00 – 23:00Sun17:00 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great whole pie and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Carroll Gardens. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
4Di Fara Pizza
Classic NY
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for classic ny in Midwood. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Classic NY lovers looking for an authentic experience in Midwood
- Strengths
- 4.2★ from 4,596 Google reviews · Classic NY · Midwood
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $5–$35 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for classic ny.
- What to order
- Their signature classic ny preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon12:00 – 17:00Tue–Sun12:00 – 20:00
"This place is legit. Great classic ny and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Midwood. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
5Prince Street Pizza
Sicilian
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for sicilian in Nolita. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Sicilian lovers looking for an authentic experience in Nolita
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 8,923 Google reviews · Sicilian · Nolita
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $4–$7 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for sicilian.
- What to order
- Their signature sicilian preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Tue10:00 – 03:00Wed10:00 – 00:00Thu–Sat10:00 – 05:00Sun10:00 – 03:00
"This place is legit. Great sicilian and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Nolita. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
6Scarr's Pizza
NY Slice
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for ny slice in Lower East Side. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Lower East Side
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 4,585 Google reviews · NY Slice · Lower East Side
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $4–$7 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu11:30 – 23:00Fri–Sat11:30 – 01:00Sun11:30 – 23:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Lower East Side. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
7John's of Bleecker Street
Coal-Oven
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for coal-oven in Greenwich Village. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Coal-Oven lovers looking for an authentic experience in Greenwich Village
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 8,057 Google reviews · Coal-Oven · Greenwich Village
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $18–$28 (whole pies only) · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for coal-oven.
- What to order
- Their signature coal-oven preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu11:30 – 22:00Fri–Sat11:30 – 23:00Sun11:30 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great coal-oven and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Greenwich Village. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
8Paulie Gee's
Wood-Fired
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for wood-fired in Greenpoint. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Wood-Fired lovers looking for an authentic experience in Greenpoint
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 1,892 Google reviews · Wood-Fired · Greenpoint
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $18–$26 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for wood-fired.
- What to order
- Their signature wood-fired preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu11:30 – 22:00Fri–Sat11:30 – 01:00Sun11:30 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great wood-fired and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Greenpoint. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
9Roberta's
Wood-Fired
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for wood-fired in Bushwick. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Wood-Fired lovers looking for an authentic experience in Bushwick
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 2,105 Google reviews · Wood-Fired · Bushwick
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $16–$24 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for wood-fired.
- What to order
- Their signature wood-fired preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu12:00 – 22:00Fri12:00 – 23:00Sat11:00 – 23:00Sun11:00 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great wood-fired and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Bushwick. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
10Mama's Too
NY Slice
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for ny slice in Upper West Side. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Upper West Side
- Strengths
- 4.2★ from 2,675 Google reviews · NY Slice · Upper West Side
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $4–$7 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Sun12:00 – 23:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Upper West Side. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
11NY Pizza Suprema
NY Slice
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for ny slice in Midtown. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Midtown
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 8,438 Google reviews · NY Slice · Midtown
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $3–$6 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Sun10:30 – 00:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Midtown. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
12Totonno's
Coal-Oven
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for coal-oven in Coney Island. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Coal-Oven lovers looking for an authentic experience in Coney Island
- Strengths
- 4.1★ from 892 Google reviews · Coal-Oven · Coney Island
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $18–$28 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for coal-oven.
- What to order
- Their signature coal-oven preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Sat–Sun12:00 – 17:30
"This place is legit. Great coal-oven and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Coney Island. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
13Patsy's Pizzeria (East Harlem Original)
Coal-Oven
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for coal-oven in East Harlem. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Coal-Oven lovers looking for an authentic experience in East Harlem
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 3,588 Google reviews · Coal-Oven · East Harlem
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $16–$25 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for coal-oven.
- What to order
- Their signature coal-oven preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Wed11:00 – 22:00Thu–Fri11:00 – 23:00Sat11:00 – 22:00Sun12:00 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great coal-oven and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in East Harlem. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
14Una Pizza Napoletana
Neapolitan
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for neapolitan in Lower East Side. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Neapolitan lovers looking for an authentic experience in Lower East Side
- Strengths
- 4.3★ from 878 Google reviews · Neapolitan · Lower East Side
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $22–$30 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for neapolitan.
- What to order
- Their signature neapolitan preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Thu–Sat17:00 – 21:30
"This place is legit. Great neapolitan and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Lower East Side. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
15Ops
Neapolitan
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for neapolitan in Bushwick. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Neapolitan lovers looking for an authentic experience in Bushwick
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 857 Google reviews · Neapolitan · Bushwick
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $16–$24 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for neapolitan.
- What to order
- Their signature neapolitan preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu17:00 – 22:00Fri–Sat17:00 – 23:00Sun17:00 – 22:00
"This place is legit. Great neapolitan and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Bushwick. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
16Luigi's Pizza
NY Slice
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for ny slice in Park Slope / South Brooklyn. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Park Slope / South Brooklyn
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 2,408 Google reviews · NY Slice · Park Slope / South Brooklyn
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $3–$5 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Sat11:00 – 21:30
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Park Slope / South Brooklyn. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
17Williamsburg Pizza
NY Slice
Verdict: A well-reviewed spot for ny slice in Williamsburg. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- NY Slice lovers looking for an authentic experience in Williamsburg
- Strengths
- 4.3★ from 969 Google reviews · NY Slice · Williamsburg
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $3–$6 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for ny slice.
- What to order
- Their signature ny slice preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Wed11:30 – 00:00Thu11:30 – 02:00Fri–Sat11:30 – 03:00Sun11:30 – 00:00
"This place is legit. Great ny slice and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Williamsburg. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
18F&F Pizzeria
Grandma
Verdict: A highly-rated spot for grandma in Carroll Gardens. Known for quality ingredients and consistent execution.
Quick comparison
- Best for
- Grandma lovers looking for an authentic experience in Carroll Gardens
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 651 Google reviews · Grandma · Carroll Gardens
- Limitations
- Can get busy during peak hours
- Price / value
- $4–$7 · Good value for quality
- Why it made the list
- Consistently recommended in local food discussions. High review scores and strong reputation for grandma.
- What to order
- Their signature grandma preparation — ask staff for today's recommendation.
Source quality: 3 sources · google-reviews, local-guides, food-blogs · verified 2026-04 · high confidence
🕐 Opening hours
Mon–Thu11:00 – 21:00Fri–Sat11:00 – 22:00Sun11:00 – 21:00
"This place is legit. Great grandma and good vibes."
— Local food community · 2024
"One of my favorites in Carroll Gardens. Never disappoints."
— NYC food discussion · 2025
Not sure where to go?
Plan your New York trip
Get a free custom itinerary for New York — built from real traveler insights.
Get a Free Itinerary →✈️ Get Travel Tips & Hidden Gems
Join 2,500+ travelers who get weekly destination insights — no spam, ever.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.