Quick answer
New York City is the steakhouse capital of America. From century-old institutions with sawdust floors and 90,000 clay pipes to Michelin-starred Korean BBQ hybrids, this guide covers 10 of the best steakhouses in NYC, with prices ranging from $80 to $250+ per person.
- Best overall
- Peter Luger Steak House — since 1887, the gold standard for porterhouse
- Price range
- $80 – $250+ per person
- Top pick
- Keens Steakhouse — $$$ — 4.5★ (6,200 reviews)
- Must-try
- Dry-aged porterhouse for two at Peter Luger or Wolfgang's
Top verdicts
- Peter Luger: The legendary Brooklyn porterhouse since 1887 — cash/debit only.
- Keens Steakhouse: NYC's oldest chophouse (1885) with the famous mutton chop.
- Cote Korean Steakhouse: Michelin-starred Korean BBQ meets NYC steakhouse — the modern standout.
New York City is the steakhouse capital of America. No other city on earth concentrates this much prime beef, this much history, and this much ambition under one skyline. From century-old institutions where robber barons once dined to Michelin-starred Korean BBQ hybrids reinventing what a steakhouse can be, NYC's steak scene is unmatched.
The city's steakhouse tradition stretches back to the 1860s, when the Meatpacking District was literally that — a working slaughterhouse neighborhood. Today, dry-aging rooms with walls of beef line the windows of Broadway restaurants, former Peter Luger waiters have launched empires of their own, and a Korean BBQ joint in the Flatiron District earned a Michelin star for its take on the American steakhouse.
Whether you want a no-frills, cash-only porterhouse in Williamsburg, a power-lunch ribeye in Midtown, or a DJ-fueled night out in the Meatpacking District, this guide has you covered.
We analyzed hundreds of Reddit posts across r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/steak, and r/nyc, cross-referencing with critic rankings from Eater NY, The Infatuation, New York Magazine, and the Michelin Guide to build this list.
Steakhouse Map
How we built this list
We analyzed 200+ Reddit posts and 2,000+ comments across r/FoodNYC, r/AskNYC, r/steak, and r/nyc, cross-referencing with rankings from Eater NY, The Infatuation, New York Magazine, Michelin Guide, and GQ. Each pick was verified for current hours, ratings, and menu accuracy as of April 2026.
All 10 Spots at a Glance
| # | Name | Style | Price | Rating | Area |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Peter Luger Steak House | Classic | $$$$ | 4.4★ | Williamsburg |
| #2 | Keens Steakhouse | Historic | $$$ | 4.5★ | Midtown |
| #3 | Wolfgang's Steakhouse | Dry-Aged | $$$ | 4.4★ | Midtown |
| #4 | Cote Korean Steakhouse | Korean BBQ | $$$$ | 4.6★ | Flatiron |
| #5 | Gallaghers Steakhouse | Historic | $$$ | 4.3★ | Theater District |
| #6 | Hawksmoor NYC | British | $$$ | 4.5★ | Gramercy |
| #7 | Benjamin Steakhouse | Classic | $$$ | 4.4★ | Midtown |
| #8 | STK Downtown | Modern | $$$ | 4.3★ | Meatpacking |
| #9 | Club A Steakhouse | Wagyu | $$$$ | 4.5★ | Upper East Side |
| #10 | Old Homestead Steakhouse | Historic | $$$$ | 4.2★ | Meatpacking |
Quick Picks by Style
1Peter Luger Steak House
ClassicQuick comparison
- Best for
- The iconic NYC steakhouse experience — porterhouse for two in a no-frills Brooklyn institution since 1887
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 8,500+ Google reviews · #1 most famous steakhouse in America · Porterhouse perfection
- Price / value
- $$$$ · 4.4★
- What to order
- The Porterhouse for Two — there is no other order. Butter-basted, charred, and served on a sizzling plate tilted so the juices pool. Add creamed spinach and German fried potatoes.
- Insider tip
- Cash or debit card only — no credit cards accepted. Reservations by phone only and book up weeks in advance. The lunch service is less crowded and just as good as dinner.
🕐 Hours
2Keens Steakhouse
HistoricQuick comparison
- Best for
- NYC history buffs who want the oldest chophouse experience with a legendary mutton chop
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 6,200+ Google reviews · Since 1885 · 90,000 clay pipes · Famous mutton chop
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.5★
- What to order
- The Mutton Chop — a massive, thick-cut chop that's been the signature since 1885. Also excellent: the prime rib and the porterhouse. Pair with a dram from their legendary scotch collection.
- Insider tip
- Look up at the ceiling — those 90,000 clay pipes belonged to famous patrons including Teddy Roosevelt, Babe Ruth, and Albert Einstein. Ask for the Lincoln Room for the most atmospheric dining.
🕐 Hours
3Wolfgang's Steakhouse
Dry-AgedQuick comparison
- Best for
- Peter Luger quality in a Manhattan setting — dry-aged porterhouse from a Luger veteran
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 4,800+ Google reviews · Dry-aged on-site · Stunning Park Ave dining room
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.4★
- What to order
- The USDA Prime Dry-Aged Porterhouse for Two — Wolfgang Zwiener learned at Luger's and brought that same philosophy of letting great beef speak for itself. The Canadian bacon appetizer is a sleeper hit.
- Insider tip
- The Park Ave location has the most impressive dining room (Guastavino tiles from the old Vanderbilt Hotel). Accepts credit cards unlike Peter Luger. Multiple NYC locations but Park Ave is the flagship.
🕐 Hours
4Cote Korean Steakhouse
Korean BBQQuick comparison
- Best for
- A modern, Michelin-starred steakhouse experience that fuses Korean BBQ with NYC fine dining
- Strengths
- 4.6★ from 3,500+ Google reviews · Michelin-starred · Tableside grills · Outstanding cocktails
- Price / value
- $$$$ · 4.6★
- What to order
- The Butcher's Feast ($175/person) — a multi-course tasting menu of dry-aged USDA Prime and A5 Wagyu grilled tableside. For a la carte, try the Dry-Aged Prime Galbi and any steak on the Josper grill.
- Insider tip
- Book on Resy but prime slots fill fast — try for early dinner (5:30 PM) on weeknights. The downstairs bar Le Sia is a speakeasy-style extension worth visiting. Don't skip the egg souffle dessert.
🕐 Hours
5Gallaghers Steakhouse
HistoricQuick comparison
- Best for
- Pre-theater dining in a classic Broadway steakhouse with a visible dry-aging room
- Strengths
- 4.3★ from 3,200+ Google reviews · Since 1927 · Dry-aging window on Broadway · Perfect for theater
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.3★
- What to order
- The dry-aged NY strip or the bone-in ribeye — both are aged in-house in the room you can see from the street. The hash browns are legendary. Great pre-fixe pre-theater menu available.
- Insider tip
- Walk by the 52nd Street window to see the dry-aging room before you go in. The pre-theater prix fixe is excellent value. Steps from virtually every major Broadway theater.
🕐 Hours
6Hawksmoor NYC
BritishQuick comparison
- Best for
- A refined British steakhouse experience with world-class cocktails in a beautiful Gramercy space
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 2,100+ Google reviews · London import · British-bred beef · Best cocktail program
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.5★
- What to order
- The bone-in prime rib or the chateaubriand for two — British-bred, grass-fed beef with a deeper, more mineral flavor than American corn-fed. Start with the shrimp burger and a cocktail.
- Insider tip
- The Sunday roast is a hidden gem — traditional British roast with all the trimmings. The bar opens before dinner and serves some of the best cocktails in Gramercy. Book through their website.
🕐 Hours
7Benjamin Steakhouse
ClassicQuick comparison
- Best for
- Classic Midtown power-lunch steakhouse with USDA Prime dry-aged beef near Grand Central
- Strengths
- 4.4★ from 2,800+ Google reviews · Peter Luger alumni · Private dining rooms · Near Grand Central
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.4★
- What to order
- The USDA Prime Dry-Aged Porterhouse for Two or the massive 40 oz. Tomahawk Ribeye. The sizzling Canadian bacon appetizer is a must, and the creamed spinach is one of the best in the city.
- Insider tip
- Located in the historic Dylan Hotel building near Grand Central — perfect for business dinners. The private dining rooms are excellent for groups. Lunch is more relaxed and equally delicious.
🕐 Hours
8STK Downtown
ModernQuick comparison
- Best for
- A night-out steakhouse with a DJ, cocktails, and Meatpacking District energy
- Strengths
- 4.3★ from 3,600+ Google reviews · DJ & lounge vibe · Prime Meatpacking location · Great for groups
- Price / value
- $$$ · 4.3★
- What to order
- The bone-in ribeye or the filet mignon. STK's signature Lil' BRGs (mini burgers) are a fun starter. The truffle fries are addictive. Come for the steak, stay for the cocktails and atmosphere.
- Insider tip
- Saturday night is the most electric vibe — DJ, low lighting, packed bar. Book early dinner (6-7 PM) for a more relaxed steak-focused meal, or later (9 PM+) for the full nightlife scene.
🕐 Hours
9Club A Steakhouse
WagyuQuick comparison
- Best for
- The ultimate splurge — Japanese A5 Wagyu, lobster mac & cheese, and UES opulence
- Strengths
- 4.5★ from 1,800+ Google reviews · Japanese Wagyu · Lobster mac & cheese · Lavish atmosphere
- Price / value
- $$$$ · 4.5★
- What to order
- The Japanese A5 Wagyu — melt-in-your-mouth richness that justifies the price. The lobster mac & cheese is loaded with whole claw meat. The tomahawk ribeye is a showstopper for sharing.
- Insider tip
- This is a celebration restaurant — birthdays, anniversaries, proposals. The staff goes all out for special occasions. Dress code leans more formal than most NYC steakhouses.
🕐 Hours
10Old Homestead Steakhouse
HistoricQuick comparison
- Best for
- NYC steakhouse history — the 3rd oldest in the city, serving since 1868 in the Meatpacking District
- Strengths
- 4.2★ from 2,400+ Google reviews · Since 1868 · Kobe beef · Historic Meatpacking location
- Price / value
- $$$$ · 4.2★
- What to order
- The Kobe beef or the USDA Prime dry-aged porterhouse. The Gotham Rib Steak is their signature cut — a massive, 28-day dry-aged bone-in ribeye. Their burgers (ground from prime cuts) are legendary for lunch.
- Insider tip
- The giant neon cow on the roof is a Meatpacking District landmark. This was a working neighborhood of butchers when Old Homestead opened in 1868 — the restaurant outlived the industry that birthed it. Great for NYC history buffs.
🕐 Hours
Planning Your NYC Steakhouse Crawl
Reservations
Reservations are essential at every steakhouse on this list. Peter Luger takes reservations by phone only — call 2-3 weeks ahead for weekends. Cote books on Resy and fills fast. Keens, Wolfgang's, Benjamin, and Gallaghers accept reservations online via OpenTable or their websites. STK Downtown can be walked into on quieter weeknights but book ahead on weekends.
Payment
Peter Luger is cash or debit card only — no credit cards accepted. All other steakhouses on this list accept all major credit cards. Budget $150-250+ per person all-in (steak, sides, drinks, tax, tip) at the $$$$ spots and $100-175 at the $$$ spots.
Best Times to Visit
Lunch service is available at Keens, Wolfgang's, Benjamin, Gallaghers, and Old Homestead — it's less crowded and often better value. For dinner, Tuesday through Thursday are the sweet spots for availability. Weekend dinner reservations should be booked 2+ weeks out at the popular spots.
Recommended Steakhouse Route
The NYC Classic Route (2 days): Day 1 lunch at Keens for the mutton chop, dinner at Cote for the Butcher's Feast. Day 2 lunch at Wolfgang's on Park Ave, then cross the bridge for dinner at Peter Luger in Williamsburg. Four legendary steakhouses, two unforgettable days.
Getting Around
Most steakhouses on this list are in Manhattan and easily accessible by subway. Peter Luger in Williamsburg is a quick L train or cab ride from Manhattan. The Midtown cluster (Keens, Wolfgang's, Benjamin, Gallaghers) is all walkable within 15 minutes. Cote and Hawksmoor are both in the Flatiron/Gramercy area. STK and Old Homestead are both in Meatpacking — walkable from each other.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Peter Luger Steak House worth it?
Yes, but with caveats. Peter Luger has been serving since 1887 and their porterhouse for two is legendary — perfectly charred, butter-basted, and served on a sizzling plate. The no-frills, cash/debit-only policy and gruff waiters are part of the experience. Reddit consensus: the steak itself is world-class, but manage expectations on service and ambiance. Go for the porterhouse, not the sides.
What's the dress code at NYC steakhouses?
Most NYC steakhouses fall into "smart casual" — collared shirts, no shorts or sneakers. Keens and Peter Luger are more relaxed (no formal dress code). Cote is upscale-casual with a trendy crowd. Club A Steakhouse and Benjamin Steakhouse lean more formal — business casual minimum. STK Downtown has a nightlife vibe so dress fashionably. When in doubt, a button-down shirt and dark jeans will get you into any steakhouse in NYC.
Do I need reservations at NYC steakhouses?
Yes — reservations are strongly recommended at virtually every steakhouse on this list. Peter Luger accepts reservations by phone only and books up weeks in advance. Cote can be booked on Resy but prime-time slots fill fast. Keens, Wolfgang's, and Benjamin all accept reservations online. For weekend dinners, book at least 1-2 weeks ahead. Walk-ins are sometimes possible at the bar.
Which NYC steakhouse is best for groups?
Peter Luger's porterhouse for 3-4 is designed for sharing. Wolfgang's and Benjamin both have private dining rooms ideal for large parties. Gallaghers has a classic, spacious layout that works well for groups of 6+. STK Downtown is the best for groups that want a social, lively atmosphere with a DJ. For a Korean BBQ group experience, Cote's Butcher's Feast tasting menu is perfect for tables of 4-6.
What's the difference between dry-aged and wet-aged steak?
Dry-aged steak is hung in a temperature-controlled room for 28-45+ days, losing moisture while developing a concentrated, nutty, funky flavor. Wet-aged steak is vacuum-sealed and aged in its own juices, resulting in a more traditional beefy flavor. Most top NYC steakhouses (Peter Luger, Wolfgang's, Gallaghers, Benjamin) specialize in dry-aging. You can literally see the aging room through the window at Gallaghers on Broadway.
How much should I budget for a NYC steakhouse dinner?
Expect to spend $100-175 per person at the $$$ steakhouses (Keens, Wolfgang's, Gallaghers, Hawksmoor, Benjamin) including a steak entree, one side, and a drink. The $$$$ spots (Peter Luger, Cote, Club A, Old Homestead) run $150-250+ per person. The porterhouse for two at Peter Luger is around $120 per person for the steak alone. Cote's Butcher's Feast tasting menu is $175 per person. Budget $200-300 per person all-in at the high end with drinks and tip.
Which steakhouse has the best cocktails and bar scene?
Cote Korean Steakhouse has an exceptional cocktail program — their soju-based cocktails and whiskey list are top-tier. Hawksmoor NYC brought London's famous cocktail culture with them and has one of the best bar programs of any steakhouse in the city. STK Downtown is the go-to if you want a full nightlife vibe with a DJ, velvet ropes, and bottle service alongside your steak. Keens also has a legendary single malt scotch collection.
What's the best steakhouse near Times Square or Broadway?
Gallaghers Steakhouse at 228 W 52nd St is the definitive pre-theater steakhouse — it's been serving the Broadway crowd since 1927 and is steps from most major theaters. Keens at 72 W 36th St is a short cab ride south. Both offer excellent food in historic settings that feel quintessentially New York. For a pre-show dinner, Gallaghers is the no-brainer pick.
🎟️ Book NYC Experiences
Tours and activities hand-picked for this guide — book with free cancellation
Experiences via Viator — free cancellation on most tours